counter

Search This Blog

Pages

Tuesday, 30 September 2008

Irish response

In the first Presidential debate, Sen. McCain said US corporation tax is too high, compared for example to Ireland (zero tax rate on exporters in the '70s and now only 12.5% on multinationals). Apart from this being like an elephant envying the flexibility of a rodent (Ireland being economically equivalent to only one of the smaller of the USA's 90 major conurbations, or economically the size of Iowa) it is officially the first EU15 state in recession (though that estimate is subject to revision).
Now, it is also leading the way in making a unique response to the financial crisis. This follows after Irish banks suffered their biggest one-day fall in shares for 20 years, yesterday, Monday. Anglo Irish, the specialist property lender, fell 45%, Irish Life & Permanent (a bancassurer and Ireland’s largest mortgage provider) fell 34%, and Allied Irish dropped 16% and Bank of Ireland lost 15%. Further to a recent tripling of depositor protection at all banks to €100,000, this protection is today extended to guarantees of an estimated €400bn of liabilities (about double Ireland’s GDP), covering not only retail, but also commercial and inter-bank deposits as well as covered bonds, senior debt and dated subordinated debt.
This is aimed at easing the banks’ short-term funding, which had seized up. The deposits covered (until Sept. 2010) are at Allied Irish Banks, Bank of Ireland, Anglo Irish Bank, Irish Life and Permanent, Irish Nationwide Building Society and Educational Building Society Shares in the 3 biggest banks rose sharply in early Dublin trading - Allied Irish up 20%, Anglo Irish up 41.3%, and Bank of Ireland up 19.3%. ”The guarantee is being provided at a charge to the institutions concerned and will be subject to specific terms and conditions so that the taxpayers’ interest can be protected,” the government said in a statement. Brian Lenihan, the finance minister, said the guarantee would make it easier for Irish banks to access funds. ”Since the collapse of several institutions in the US, it has been very difficult to access funds on international markets for Irish banks,” he said. “This will present real problems for the Irish economy if it is not addressed.”
In much larger economies the authorities sometimes allow a bank to fail pour encourager les autres, but that is not likely here. The public is also exposed via falling house prices of course, via the stock market (pensions etc.) and direct and indirect as bondholders. Most Irish equities are foreign-owned and so the market is vulnerable to the global bigger picture, which is confused and hence it became necessary for Ireland to make its own decisive move. No governments elsewhere have offered protection for bondholders and investments in shares in banks’ bonds by pension funds etc.; shareholders remain at full risk. I have every confidence in the government and the financial regulator, why 20% of my liquid portfolio continues to reside in Irish banks.
The Irish government is finalising its October Budget. It is mindful of the idea that a failed banking system is a failed state and that there was some cricism of the fact that Irish banks required as much of the ECB's liquidity window as Spain! Ireland recognises it has to find a solution of its own when the rest of the world appears to be stumbling from one intervention to the next, hence the innovation of a wider deposit cover (albeit that the banks have to also pay towards this). The Irish Government has one of the lowest Government Debt/GDP ratios in the EU (one benefit of being in the EU currency zone, albeit that private external debt/GDP may be relatively high?). Ireland has a high soverign credit rating, but credit ratings, as we have seen, are vaporous in a liquidity crisis, and like everywhere else banks' liquidity, despite ample credit risk grades, is in precious short supply. It also has, in common with other credit boom economies, a high trade deficit of 8% ratio to GDP, compared to UK at 6%, Spain and 5%, but Greece at over 10%!

Monday, 29 September 2008

The Great D word is in play.

It's my working assumption that a new agreement will be reached in the U.S. and/or the Fed, US Treasury, the ECB, BoE and other central banks will now work on an international/global version of the TARP concept. The international dimension was lacking anyway, and might not require any parliamentary scrutiny, debate and votes?
Equity values are a major part of the 'own capital' of publicly quoted financial institutions. Banks, especially publicly quoted banks, need to replenish sizeable chunks of their capital (regulatory reserves) urgently, ideally by replacing toxic own assets with AAA government treasuries, any OECD governments' treasuries.
Assuming some global scheme can be cobbled together over the next few days, I would then expect the stock markets to recover substantially from this week's sell-off and end the year in positive territory. Equities are also now getting to extreme valuations where fundamentally there is an awful lot of value for those prepared and sufficiently flush to buy on or below book values.
Meanwhile I bet many millions of private and institutional investors will be crowding into Treasuries, Gold and other safe harbour money protection funds such as the bigger most reputable money market funds, just as Hedge Funds have done, by parking sums equivalent in size to what TARP envisaged investing. Millions too will be looking up the 1929 Crash and the Great Depression. Few experts believe that is where we are headed now, at least not any distance downwards beyond the initial crash ratios. In 1924-'29 stocks rose by 120% and then in two days in October (Black Tuesday and Black Thursday) lost 30% and then continued sliding so that by 1932 a further 60% was wiped i.e. 90% of stock market indices gone.
I recall from my economics studies that Irving Fisher, the leading US economist was heavily invested and bullish, but lost his entire wealth (including his house). In the UK, JM Keynes also lost heavily. Were lessons learned? Samuelson admitted half a century later that "playing as I often do the experiment of studying price profiles with their dates concealed, I discovered that I would have been caught by the 1929 debacle." Hence, then and since, market collapses (almost by definition) were not foreseeable, whether or not they were inevitable! Moreover, that big brain economists, then and now, can neither anticipate the timing nor explain big market drops, the idea that stocks were obviously overpriced and had to fall to regain true value is a myth, and yet one of the objections by US legislators as well as the IASB accountants is that today's mark to market valuations of toxic assets are their true values? This was a major objection to the US Treasury's TARP scheme; the idea that it is not a waste of tax dollars to buy assets at prices above their current (distressed) market valuations.
What most people do not understand is that asset values are all market values and market values are produced by the economic system, its total circular, recycling of money stocks and flows plus confidence plus expectations, not by factory production productivity, or fundamental commodity or labour values. Wealth is not created by individuals or firms, but by all people and all firms within a gaming system of rules governed by expectations of how these apply normally.
If we take a casino analogy, Governments are 'the house' and they have to do whatever they can to attract everyone to remain winning and losing at the tables, rich and poor, all cosseted by their expectations and their confidence in the system and the rules, and with a few safety nets so that rich get taxed and the money recycled to the poor to keep them playing too, otherwise the rich will become poor too. A small majority of Congressional legislators ignored such circularity and all were attracted or compelled by the idea of changing the odds dramatically so as to protect Main Street versus Wall Street, and too by conservatives who identify freedom with the laws of chance operating freely with only minimalist government intervention. Some of them also want to replay the political-economic game of The Great Depression, this time without FDR's New Deal, which is their by-word for Socialism; to this time round prove that pure capitalism works.
If economic history taught me anything, I learned that Capitalism to survive needs Socialism in the engine room, just as Communism or Socialism need Capitalism in the engine room!

On the floor

"We need to put something back together that works," Hank Paulson said after he and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke joined an emergency meeting at the White House. On the Hill, Democratic leaders said the House would reconvene Thursday, leaving open the possibility of a TARP salvage version as all sides promised further efforts, but clearly there is confusion between saving bankers and saving the financial system. One third of Democrats and two thirds of Republicans and many or most of those up for re-election in 5 weeks' time voted against TARP, impressed by thousands of phone calls and e-mails fiercely opposing the measure. The House Web site was overwhelmed as millions of people sought information about the measure through the day.
Hoping to pick up enough GOP votes for the next try, Republicans floated several ideas. One would double the $100,000 ceiling on federal deposit insurance. Another would end rules that require companies to devalue assets on their books to reflect the price they could get in the market. As a digital screen in the House chamber recorded a cascade of "no" votes against the bailout, Democratic Rep. Joe Crowley of New York shouted news of the falling Dow Jones industrials. "Six hundred points!" he yelled, jabbing his thumb downward and a lot of partisan finger-pointing followed the vote. The Dow fell to 777 points down, far surpassing the 684-drop on the first trading day after 9/11.
"What happened today was not a failure of a bill, it was a failure of will," said Dodd, the Banking Committee chairman. "Our hope is that cooler heads will prevail, people will think about what they did today and recognize that this is not just scare tactics — it's reality." Republicans blamed Pelosi's scathing speech near the close of the debate — which assailed Bush's economic policies and a "right-wing ideology of anything goes, no supervision, no discipline, no regulation" of financial markets — for the defeat. Rep. Roy Blunt, R-Mo., the whip, estimated that Pelosi's speech changed the minds of a dozen Republicans who might otherwise have supported the plan. Rep. Barney Frank, chair of the Financial Services Committee said of those Republicans, "Because somebody hurt their feelings, they decide to punish the country."
McCain said his rival Barack Obama and congressional Democrats "infused unnecessary partisanship into the process. Now is not the time to fix the blame; it's time to fix the problem." Obama said, "Democrats, Republicans, step up to the plate, get it done." Campaign politics could not be removed from this, no more than Pelosi could resist attacking conservative ideology in what was supposed to be bipartisanship!
There was enormous pressure from angry emotional public opinion and powerful voters' groups giving notice they considered TARP a "key vote" when rating members of Congress. "Make no mistake: When the aftermath of congressional inaction becomes clear, Americans will not tolerate those who stood by and let the calamity happen," said R. Bruce Josten, of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, in a letter to all members. The conservative Club for Growth made a similar threat to supporters of the bailout. "We're all worried about losing our jobs," Rep. Paul Ryan, declared in an impassioned speech in support of the bill before the vote. "Most of us say, 'I want this thing to pass, but I want you to vote for it — not me.' We're in this moment, and if we fail to do the right thing, Heaven help us."

Politics wins

Would you adam and eve it, turkeys vote for Christmas 228 to 205? There will be another attempt tomorrow to hammer out some new ideas, but nothing on the floor of Congress before our teatime on Thursday - Congress is adjourned. The debaters in the House of Representatives had fair value warnings of the abyss
Nasdaq down 9%, Dow down 7% (biggest one day drop), S&P 500 down 7%. Wachovia (down 90% overnight) and other banks are now teetering. Treasury yields down and interbank liquidity lending rates remain very dry. Central banks led by the US Fed are tripling money market liquidity windows. Citigroup shares fell, and shares of financial stocks traded lower. Morgan Stanley fell 11 percent and Goldman Sachs was off 8% and ticking down. European stocks, already 3% down at the New York open, fell more after the falls on Wall Street. London and Paris down over 5 %, Frankfurt -4%, Asia, Hong Kong ditoo.
Slides are bound to continue tomorrow, maybe all week; could a 40% fall to long term p/e rates in the US and 25% in Europe be far off? Maybe the House Republicans didn't realise they could defeat the bill, wanting only to lay down a strong protest marker. We'll find out from TARP's media autopsy. It will be unusual if various alternatives, PLan Bs, do not get an airing. After all, half of US households have stock investments.
Willem Buiter says in the FT Those whom the gods would destroy, they first make mad "Opposition to the proposal came from two different sources. A few remaining libertarians and believers in unfettered free enterprise voted against. Even when they recognise the risk that a calamitous collapse in economic activity may result, they view this as a form of creative destruction that is an integral part of a Darwinian market economy. I don’t know anything about Gresham Barrett, a Republican congressman from South Carolina but his statement fits the bill: “My fear is the government will be forever changing the face of the American free market. Because I believe so strongly in the principles of the free market and the belief in freedom, I will be opposing this bill.” Those who genuinely hold these views are mad, but honest and principled. I wish them a good depression."

Toxic pricing

TARP is one thing and global stock markets are all looking at a hefty 5% fall (US & Europe indices back to where they were a year ago) led by oils (oil futures off by oer 7%) and banking sectors down together. Central banks announced more co-ordinated action to combat the credit crisis and boost dollar liquidity, and the US Fed will more than double its swap lines with the ECB and other central banks from $290bn to $620bn (why not $700bn?) and it's expanding its Term Auction Facilities programme.
The FT suggests that one of the hardest to do aspects of TARP will be pricing somewhere between current firesale and hold to maturity valuations. It is not that hard to calculate between firesale and through the cycle fair value; the hedge funds are making those analyses, and have been doing so for months. They are supremely confident that they can profit by them. The bigger problem for TARP is answering why a bank or investor would seek to sell to TARP given the penalties of doing so, which may be more deadly to the value and risk grade standing of the asset seller than the funding boost is beneficial! Therefore, what may happen is that others (the shady shadow bankers, of types known as prime brokers, AI, Distress Real Estate, Global Macro, Vulture, Hedge, and Raptor, funds) will copycat TARP minus the reputational risks in return for a softer price that discounts TARP's prices.(note: those asking what is a Raptor Fund may like to know that raptors are birds of prey characterized by a hooked beak, sharp talons, and keen eyesight such as buzzards and sparrowhawks that prey along our hedgerows for rabbits and smaller birds and vermin, a type of fund that I believe will soon catch on. Raptor is also the Lockheed Martin/ Boeing F22 stealth fighter aircraft that entered service in December 2005 just as house prices began falling!)

TARP Day 1

The House votes today, the Senate today or tomorrow? TARP is assumed to be deeply unpopular. FTSE100 is down 2% (11am) with HBoS -10%, Europe -3%, after Asia fell 3%. In the US, Wachovia and Wells Fargo stocks are bullish, but the test will come on market opening. It seems the credibility of political and regulatory governance is being doubted. In the UK, B&B's takeover by a combination of Government (N.Rock) and Santander, and of Fortis by the three Benelux governments, and Hypo Real Estate handed €35bn credit guarantees by the German government and other banks, are discomfiting and so banks' shares are down again.
Fortis returned an excellent 2007 with ample assurances and yet has been massacred - disbelieved, shorted, rumoured to be under regulatory pressure, cash-flow weak (liquidity mismatch on assets to deposits and equity) though otherwise solvent? I know a lot more about this (and other banks) than I am legally entitled to reveal. Suffice to say such problems are not unique and Fortis is fundamentally a good and great bank staffed by honest diligent professionals who (as the CEO himself said) cannot comprehend why what is happening to them?)
All banks without exception have experienced enormous difficulties in designing and implementing systems to comply with Basel II; there is only so much true expertise available and not nearly enough to go round. Everyone has been on the steepest possible learning curve that inevitably results in errors. This is the first generation of Basel II solutions. Second and third generations will be orders of magnitude better. Similarly, the originate-to-distribute business model and all its structured credit product derivatives was a first generation nascent market that outgrew all expectations (of those who first invented it) at an unforeseen speed. Market corrections of earlier new derivatives markets were severe and some of us expected and warned that this would happen to CDOs etc. but no-one predicted the systemic scale of such a collapse.
Some of us could forecast the impact on banks' capital of economic recessions requiring up to 90% of banks' capital reserves to be replenished, but none I know foresaw that banks' equity capitalisations would fall by 70-95%!
Official figures on who is or is not experiencing recession right now have to be discounted. Core GDP data is subject to major revisions for up to two years. There is a historical pattern to the world's economic and credit cycles in terms of the knock-on lags from one to the other e.g. first the USA, then UK&I two quarters later, then the rest of Europe 6-8 quarters after that. But, equity markets and banks' liquidity risks do not walk in precise tandem with macro-economic cycles. These matters, the shocks that disrupt firms' economic capital models cannot be precisely forecast. Flawed human judgement is necessary and time needs to be bought to climb out of shock events. That is the essence of Government intervention, buying the time, not in weeks or months but years, for financial firms, their clients and customers, to win through to recovery, to regain near normal orderly markets. This requires confidence, realism and fortitude. For this, we can only rely on past recovery experience.
We know that property falls bottom out when they hit their long-run growth rates. The only reliable buy signals come from cyclically adjusted (over-the-cycle fair value, not through-the-cycle aggregate fair value, and not point-in-time or marking to market) i.e. price/earnings ratios that adjust for cycles such as profits/wages shares in the macro-economy. The US equity market is 40% above its long term fair value. Some argue this is because recession has been postponed by the governments' liquidity infusions, while others say this is belied by unemployment data i.e. equity fundamentals have already run over the cliff edge but values not yet recognised this? Elsewhere, the MSCI emeging markets index trades at an earings multiple 25% below the world index and FTSE-Eurofirst at below half the multiple of the S&P500 i.e. both much cheaper than the USA. Therefore, as John Authers (FT 27 Sept.) concludes the idea that resolving the banking crisis "will lead to a new bull market should be tested".
In my view, if TARP restores confidence in US financial assets without an equivalent intervention immediately in Europe, the dollar/Euro rate may recover its rise that began in July. Sterling today has its worst intra-day against the dollar for 15 years and the euro is also down; £ falling 2% to $1.8022 and euro lost 1.2% to $1.4346, on hopes of the TARP plan. World oil (& other commodities including Gold?) prices that rose briefly in recent days after a prolonged weakening may again soften and fall, even continuing to do so as we enter Winter demand, and thereby underpinning a fourth quarter general rise in market confidence (and Obama victory at the polls, Nov.4?), and then I expect turbulent volatility to be disruptively back in play by late January until Spring. Oil prices fell today by more than $3 a barrel while gold prices dipped and base metals retreated. But, what can I know - I was predicting a bank sector bounce, but maybe that has first to wait on TARP being voted through?

Sunday, 28 September 2008

Compromised TARP - likely to fail ?

Reuters reports (lunchtime EST & teatime GMT) that (after 9 hours including some through the night and "into the wee hours of Sunday morning") US Congress leaders (both parties) emerged to announce TARP agreed (with provisos to protect Main Street). "We've made great progress," said Speaker Nancy Pelosi (just in time for the opening of East Asia's stock markets). Agreement is subject to a House and Senate vote (Monday). And some further adjustments might appear by then. (The only alternative to not agreeing TARP, or this baby Son of TARP (my take on this sub-version of the original plan), was a back-of-the-envelope insurance proposal by House Republicans, which by Friday's 'Presidential debate #1' had been heaped with derision such that Sen. McCain was in some shock and now recognising that he has to be seen as a promoter not an obstacle to agreement. Nevertheless as a sop to McCain and his party the insurance deal survives as an add-on to TARP! But that's not the only watering-down. Re-election sensitive legislators have been intimidated by constituents' mails on a ratio of about 50-1 against the bail-out.)
As you will see below, I doubt the financial system will be adequately stabilised by this TARP (Troubled Asset Relief Program), even though the lawmakers consulted Warren Buffett (who confirmed his view that markets are verging on melt-down. Note that his $5bn investment in Goldman Sachs may have a clause dependency on TARP, but it now seems Goldmans may not access TARP directly, nor need to,having reduced its sub-prime exposure to a very trivial amount? Instead it is setting yup a $50bn fund to buy distressed financial assets!) There are seven parts to TARP, that are likely to dilute market confidence and undermine the overall purpose of TARP?
1. The first $250bn will be issued on TARP's enactment at US Treasury's discretion but with additional oversight, while another $100bn as The President decides, and $350bn subject to Congressional review. 'troubled assets' will be bought on a partnership basis with the warrant issuing institutions and small banks whereby the Fed/Treasury gain the upside and the warrant issuers bear any net loss.
2. Institutions selling assets (toxic) under the plan will issue stock warrants giving "taxpayers an ownership stake and profit-making opportunities with participating companies," . "Institutions" means pension plans, local governments and small banks. This may leave some big banks who are at the centre of the crisis bereft, to say the least!
3. Given the clamour of the Sans Culottes for de-capitations of executives' bonus-pay, no execs at participating companies may be allowed to get multi-million-dollar severance pay and CEO pay will be capped (a boost for shareholder activism and court cases e.g. "you should have issued stock warrants, but didn't just to defend your salary!", and Boards will have the whip hand over CEOs by threatening to vote to go to TARP and bang goes most of the CEO's pay).
4. An oversight board of top officials, including the Federal Reserve chairman, will supervise the programme, while its management also will be under close scrutiny by Congress' investigative arm and an independent inspector general (independent meaning what, from where?). What is extraordinary about this is that the current oversight of the Fed and US Treasury seem forgotten about and this additional oversight is only for the first $250bn at their discretion, while Congress gets discretion over half the money, $350bn.
5. The deal also requires "meaningful judicial review of the Treasury secretary's actions," which suggests to me that Hank Paulson won't be staying on after January!
6. the Government could use its power as the owner of mortgages and mortgage-backed securities to help more struggling homeowners modify the terms of their home loans (which will require an immense amount of inter-firm database look-up computing when a cleverer deal might have been to create an exchange plus clearing house, but that could still materialise?)
7. Institutions selling toxic assets to the TARP fund can have a supervisory board imposed on them and in an case thereby signal publicly that they are in a condition bordering insolvency, in which case they risk a run on their equity, loss of creditor confidence and probable ratings downgrade. These reputational risk factors will prevent firms from applying to TARP until they have no other choice, in which case the dire implication of the conditions become self-fulfilling!
Meanwhile elsewhere in the forest another tree crashes. Wachovia Corp, the sixth-largest U.S. bank, is in merger talks with potential partners after a 27% drop in its shares on Friday. (US Investors worried about a contagion effect have been shifting funds to Japan and into Europe. But, in Europe big banks are also wallowing, especially Fortis NV whose fate is infecting the Belgian political crisis and lies in the hands of the Dutch National Bank who has the right to cancel its takeover of ABN-AMRO Netherlands in Q3 next year if it has not already had to be taken over before then by possibly ING and a French bank?
In London, regulators are parcelling off Bradford & Bingley. And in Switzerland banks may be capped on both proprietary trading and assets in ratio to equity - a dramatic restriction if it catches on across Europe and/or across the Atlantic!)
The TARP bad bank bailout bill ends a dramatic two weeks (or one week as one banker opined, in which markets have changed more than in the past 70 years, which seems absurdly dramatic and ignorant to me).
On Friday, on Capital Hill at in and out of the Oval Office some involvees were saying presidential politics and politics per se must be kept out of this. But as the caveats above show, politics is in the mix, albeit bipartisan. WAMU's collapse, the classic Main Street bank, concentrated minds as to the idea that Main Street could be protected from Wall Street. The New Deal (ooops) on Tarp looks to be far more biased to saving Main Street than saving the wholesale interbank liquidity crisis. In this respect, it may be that the deal is now 90 degrees off-kilter and will not do at all what Hank Paulson and Ben Bernanke need and want? Remember, we still do not know where all the toxic ABS is held?
And, unbelievably as a final further sop, House Republicans won support for a provision that would create a privately funded insurance programme for mortgage-backed securities.
As with any big money programmes, there are many pigs at the trough but not all get fed. Democrats barred proposals to put money into a trust fund for affordable housing and the idea of allowing court judges the right to alter the terms of mortgage contracts for bankrupt borrowers.
The big shocker (if it is surprising really?) is that the new deal reflects not only popular suspicion of the Bush Administration, but also represents an extraordinary demotion for the Fed and the US Treasury (with all their various arms, Comptroller of the Currency, FDIC, Fannie & Freddy, AIG, regulatory authority, management of the Federal Debt etc.) This may not matter that much to 'TarPaulson' as he may now depart when the Bush Presidency hands over in January, but must be a blow to Ben Bernanke whose authority and prestige are vital to financial market confidence and monetary management, even though he will chair the TARP oversight board.
Paulson and Bernanke have recently spend hundreds of $billions including at least $30bn extended to Europe. This may not be permitted so easily again! The politicians have exacted a mighty price to pass TARP. I would not be surprised if the Fed and the US Treasury would, if they but could, ideally wish to go back to the drawing board and conceive another technical solution that removes the necessity to go forward with politically-motivated provisos, except too late for that?