Obama and McCain will after all debate tonight in the university in Oxford, Mississippi. Bob Dylan wrote the song "Oxford Town," for The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan, about the violence over the admission of black man James Meredith into the University in 1962. Will there be demonstrators there tonight calling for government to defend their homes and mortgaages, maybe some out of work realtors and mortgage brokers too, but unlikely to see Wall Street suits campaigning to save their bonuses. The great Nobel prize-winning master of southern Gothic William Faulkner comes from there and John Grisham lives there.
Faulkner's last novel ends with a race. Lucius rides Coppermine in an illicit race. Coppermine likes to run just behind the other horses to monitor them at all times, but Ned,the black stableboy, bribes him with a sardine for a final burst to win the race. After the win, for the next race, Ned does not do the sardine trick and Coppermine loses. Ned had shorted (bet heavily against) Coppermine in this race, and the black kid thereby gets the better of the rich whites. Tonight, Obama and McCain will debate there and the key subject will be TARP; will it save the world as we know it or not?
McCain was originally keen to cancel the debate in favour of getting involved in the bad bank deal. His brinkmanship has scuppered TARP for now and his closest advisors told him to get out of town (Washington) because he was seen merely as getting in the way and obstructing a deal. Obama said he never wanted to cancel the debate; he wanted to address the nation about the financial crisis.
Congress will remain in session over the weekend. All representatives and congressmen will be watching the Oxford debate. So, what are we in for? Probably an amzing attempt to translate high falutin' finance into campaign stump-speak followed by Congressional debates where one third of the representatives who are up for re-election also speaking stump - totally grippingly sound-bite seering reality teevee at its very best. Who'll win these races?
Meanwhile, at the UN, another Presidential speech today. Gordon Brown announces the end of the age of irresponsibility and global turbulence, perhaps herlding in the age of responsibility and calm? "Confidence in the future is needed to build confidence today," he said.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/sep/25/internationalaidanddevelopment.gordonbrown1
This site gets over 1,000 hits a week, and over 1,000 downloads of related papers by R.McDowell - an applied economist, wholesale, retail banking with 25+ years in banking, strategy, front office, trading book, banking book, core banking, audit, Head of Risk, PM roles & Basel II & Solv II Subject Matter Expert with 'Risk Dynamics' of Brussels.
Friday, 26 September 2008
Politicking under the TARPaulin
Barney Frank, chairman of the House financial service committee said “I worry about this politicisation of it.” Of course, bound to be when it can eclipse the final weeks of the Presidential campaign. Both McCain and Obama have to use the grandstanding opportunity to look the more presidential. One fear is that Bush may feel politically that he should veto TARP so as not to diadvantage McCain who now supports the mortgage insurance scheme Republican alternative. This may not have majority Republoican support on the Hill, but it may be enough that McCain supports this whose capacity for anger-filled stubborness is legendary.
It is axiomatic in politics and international diplomacy that any great issue regardless of its technical, moral or ethical merits, is politically tradable. What are the political stakes. Bush has to be anxious that the next White House does not reopen all the cans of worms concerning the Iraq War, its origin, planning and prosecution and the $billions in missing procurement contracts, and the undeniable scope for corruption legal cases. A potage of financial crises left in the lap of an incoming Democratic Administration may also suit the outgoing Bush team.
These are intensely cynical conjectures. Bush may also ache to be seen rounding off his 2 terms by decisively saving US Banking Inc. from its "Pearl Harbor" (W.Buffett).
There is a proposed compromise on the table - to modified TARP to prevent “inappropriate executive compensation for participating companies”.
Paulson recognises the dilemma this poses. Will $30-$40m remunerated CEOs and their multi-millions earning "star performers" and high roller investment teams agree to save their banks if it means personally losing $millions? The compromise also would allow the Fed/ US Treasury/ FDIC etc. to take stakes in banks assisted under the plan and appoint its own oversight boards. The dilemma here is that participation in TARP automatically designates a bank as in chronic straits and would trigger some complex problems for the ratings agencies. To be able to borrow unsecured a bank or insurance company needs at least AA- status.
By teatime, the deal had fallen asunder; politicians going to the wire. McCain is cornered and Obama askance. A group of neo-liberal House Republicans had circulated an alternative plan for an emergency insurance fund for financial institutions instead of buying in troubled mortgage assets (TARP). What does this do to the $50 trillions of CDSs? Will the insurance be written on the distressed assets at current firesale prices, or at higher discounted cashflow & TTC prices? Are CDSs suddenly worth something or in fact worth nothing? Does McCain care or will he call in all favours and yank on every political lever to get his alternative accepted and win the Presidential race in one bound? Will Obama, astride a bipartisan fence, fall off or garner enough majority support on the floor of The House to win the Presidency, in the course of which he enters office with a bunch of favours owing to the other side? I'm reminded of the reputed (maybe only a rumour) deal between Clinton and Bush senior a fortnight before the end of the 1992 campaign when Bush agreed to back off campaigning in the final days if Clinton agreed not to pursue legal actions over the Iran-Contra scandal or seek to undo Bush's presidential pardons to individuals involved. Iran-Contra subsequently disappeared totally form the media and political landscape.
But neither OBama or McCain are backing down. Are the two campaign teams burning up the lines to Capitol Hill? They must be. The gloves were off and the big fight arena marked out when negotiations exploded into an emotion-filled slanging match (books will be written - Random House or Harper Collins or Atlantic Books, get in there now!) and it even had some knightly drama. Nancy Pelosi, the speaker, has made it clear she wants the unpopular bail-out legislation to be agreed on a bipartisan basis including the grisly modifications such as capping executive bonuses. Adding to the hundreds already arrested by the FBI is clearly not enough. Hank Paulson then, after the fracas, knelt down in front of Ms Pelosi, ring-kissingly imploring for her help in passing the legislation as planned. Meanwhile, a Treasury spokeswoman issued a statement urging members of “both parties” to complete the legislation quickly on the basis that “There are still open issues to be resolved, and we are committed to resolving them”. That may no longer be true?
UK, Europe and Japan finished the day 2% down, while the S&P 500 finished up 2% despite profits warning from GE that was matched by $25bn aid for Detroit motors. The dollar was broadly firmer and Treasury yields had risen, and no one paid any mind to Peer Steinbrück, the German finance minister, saying "The US will lose its role as a global financial “superpower” in the wake of the financial crisis (blaming Washington for failing to take the regulatory steps that might have averted crisis) adding “This world will become multipolar” with the emergence of stronger, better capitalised centres in Asia and Europe, The world will never be the same again.” This is wishful thinking and diplomacy of the shallowest kind.
Conditions in the money markets remain in deep doodoo; short-term rates hardening and lending beyond overnight paralysed in intensive care, and nowhere more so than in Europe, not just in the US. Hans Jorg Rudloff, BarCap's chairman, said: “Anyone looking at the money markets would come to the conclusion that we are one minute before a terminal heart attack. Therefore the rescue package will pass. There is no choice.” But, has he reckoned with what happens when two enormous forces super-collide, a fully transparant US Presidential campaign and the dark forces of shadow-banking; brings to mind the Wildean quip, the unspeakable in pursuit of the uneatable?
Meanwhile, reading down the small-print, new data revealed the massive increase in Fed liquidity support over the past week, including $73bn in indirect loans to money market funds and a doubling of direct lending to investment banks and primary dealers.
All may stumble on down the dark cavernous maze like Theseus unravelling Ariadne's ball given her by the high flying Daedelus to slay the bull Minotaur to be played out at first presidential debate, scheduled for prime time Friday.
It is axiomatic in politics and international diplomacy that any great issue regardless of its technical, moral or ethical merits, is politically tradable. What are the political stakes. Bush has to be anxious that the next White House does not reopen all the cans of worms concerning the Iraq War, its origin, planning and prosecution and the $billions in missing procurement contracts, and the undeniable scope for corruption legal cases. A potage of financial crises left in the lap of an incoming Democratic Administration may also suit the outgoing Bush team.
These are intensely cynical conjectures. Bush may also ache to be seen rounding off his 2 terms by decisively saving US Banking Inc. from its "Pearl Harbor" (W.Buffett).
There is a proposed compromise on the table - to modified TARP to prevent “inappropriate executive compensation for participating companies”.
Paulson recognises the dilemma this poses. Will $30-$40m remunerated CEOs and their multi-millions earning "star performers" and high roller investment teams agree to save their banks if it means personally losing $millions? The compromise also would allow the Fed/ US Treasury/ FDIC etc. to take stakes in banks assisted under the plan and appoint its own oversight boards. The dilemma here is that participation in TARP automatically designates a bank as in chronic straits and would trigger some complex problems for the ratings agencies. To be able to borrow unsecured a bank or insurance company needs at least AA- status.
By teatime, the deal had fallen asunder; politicians going to the wire. McCain is cornered and Obama askance. A group of neo-liberal House Republicans had circulated an alternative plan for an emergency insurance fund for financial institutions instead of buying in troubled mortgage assets (TARP). What does this do to the $50 trillions of CDSs? Will the insurance be written on the distressed assets at current firesale prices, or at higher discounted cashflow & TTC prices? Are CDSs suddenly worth something or in fact worth nothing? Does McCain care or will he call in all favours and yank on every political lever to get his alternative accepted and win the Presidential race in one bound? Will Obama, astride a bipartisan fence, fall off or garner enough majority support on the floor of The House to win the Presidency, in the course of which he enters office with a bunch of favours owing to the other side? I'm reminded of the reputed (maybe only a rumour) deal between Clinton and Bush senior a fortnight before the end of the 1992 campaign when Bush agreed to back off campaigning in the final days if Clinton agreed not to pursue legal actions over the Iran-Contra scandal or seek to undo Bush's presidential pardons to individuals involved. Iran-Contra subsequently disappeared totally form the media and political landscape.
But neither OBama or McCain are backing down. Are the two campaign teams burning up the lines to Capitol Hill? They must be. The gloves were off and the big fight arena marked out when negotiations exploded into an emotion-filled slanging match (books will be written - Random House or Harper Collins or Atlantic Books, get in there now!) and it even had some knightly drama. Nancy Pelosi, the speaker, has made it clear she wants the unpopular bail-out legislation to be agreed on a bipartisan basis including the grisly modifications such as capping executive bonuses. Adding to the hundreds already arrested by the FBI is clearly not enough. Hank Paulson then, after the fracas, knelt down in front of Ms Pelosi, ring-kissingly imploring for her help in passing the legislation as planned. Meanwhile, a Treasury spokeswoman issued a statement urging members of “both parties” to complete the legislation quickly on the basis that “There are still open issues to be resolved, and we are committed to resolving them”. That may no longer be true?
UK, Europe and Japan finished the day 2% down, while the S&P 500 finished up 2% despite profits warning from GE that was matched by $25bn aid for Detroit motors. The dollar was broadly firmer and Treasury yields had risen, and no one paid any mind to Peer Steinbrück, the German finance minister, saying "The US will lose its role as a global financial “superpower” in the wake of the financial crisis (blaming Washington for failing to take the regulatory steps that might have averted crisis) adding “This world will become multipolar” with the emergence of stronger, better capitalised centres in Asia and Europe, The world will never be the same again.” This is wishful thinking and diplomacy of the shallowest kind.
Conditions in the money markets remain in deep doodoo; short-term rates hardening and lending beyond overnight paralysed in intensive care, and nowhere more so than in Europe, not just in the US. Hans Jorg Rudloff, BarCap's chairman, said: “Anyone looking at the money markets would come to the conclusion that we are one minute before a terminal heart attack. Therefore the rescue package will pass. There is no choice.” But, has he reckoned with what happens when two enormous forces super-collide, a fully transparant US Presidential campaign and the dark forces of shadow-banking; brings to mind the Wildean quip, the unspeakable in pursuit of the uneatable?
Meanwhile, reading down the small-print, new data revealed the massive increase in Fed liquidity support over the past week, including $73bn in indirect loans to money market funds and a doubling of direct lending to investment banks and primary dealers.
All may stumble on down the dark cavernous maze like Theseus unravelling Ariadne's ball given her by the high flying Daedelus to slay the bull Minotaur to be played out at first presidential debate, scheduled for prime time Friday.
UK Europe steps forward
Further to the view that Euopean banks are even more anxious than their US counterparts for TARP, and to help concentrate minds further, the Bank of England said today it would extend $30bn in cash for a week against eligible collateral i.e. re-opening SLS, though also drawing on currency swap lines put in place earlier with the US Fed. "These operations are intended to address funding pressures over quarter-end," said the Bank ($10bn available for overnight borrowing, though it had agreed to provide $40bn daily in overnight money last week, but so far, there was not the demand for the full amount (for interesting reasons not explored here, that may or may not have had something to do with shotgun wedding of HBoS and LTSB).
Even drier than overnight is 3months money and hence, BoE says it will inject longer term money into sterling markets. Retail banks especially need 3 month money as they pre-order their funding on a quarterly basis.
(It was when Northern Rock couldn't book its next quarter's funds that it had to go begging to the BoE that triggered the bank run). BoE says it'll extend long-term repo operations against extended collateral, including mortgages. As from Tuesday next it will offer £40bn for maturity on January 15 (through year end, and by which time the Democratic Administration will be installed, when TARP if it incredibly fails to pass now will surely be passed then?). UK Bankers welcomed the news. Similar actions will be taken by ECB and other central banks in Europe.
Even drier than overnight is 3months money and hence, BoE says it will inject longer term money into sterling markets. Retail banks especially need 3 month money as they pre-order their funding on a quarterly basis.
(It was when Northern Rock couldn't book its next quarter's funds that it had to go begging to the BoE that triggered the bank run). BoE says it'll extend long-term repo operations against extended collateral, including mortgages. As from Tuesday next it will offer £40bn for maturity on January 15 (through year end, and by which time the Democratic Administration will be installed, when TARP if it incredibly fails to pass now will surely be passed then?). UK Bankers welcomed the news. Similar actions will be taken by ECB and other central banks in Europe.
Market Buffetting
After Warren Buffett buying into Goldman Sachs ($5bn preferred stock with guaranteed 10% dividend, for his 'brand value') which he is now earning by warning that the US financial system faces an "economic Pearl Harbor". (Not only the US, but Europe too of course!) We now have a pearl-handled starting gun waiting to fire up the markets. He ordered Congress to pass Paulson's TARP ($700bn "bad bank"), to allow firms to sell toxic assets. Speaking to CNBC the "sage of Omaha", 77, commented: I'm not saying the Paulson plan will eliminate the problems but it's absolutely necessary, in my view, to avoid going off the precipice." He added: "I bet they'll make a profit…I would love to have $700 billion at treasury rates to buy fixed-income securities - there's a lot of money to be made."
Global trade patterns reverse
The credit crunch is a bursting ballon that had inflated to historic proportion over the last decade. The US (and some others like the UK) $1tn trade deficit (worth half of China's GDP) was paid for largely by foreign acquisition of US financial assets-backed paper. The credit boom economies ran deficits and the export-led growth economies collected foreign currency reserves.
Then this Summer China's growth reversed to become mainly explained by internal not external demand (falling trade surplus) and US growth mainly by external not internal demand (falling trade deficit). Now, yesterday, we learn that Japan has recorded its first outright trade deficit in 25 years!
Then this Summer China's growth reversed to become mainly explained by internal not external demand (falling trade surplus) and US growth mainly by external not internal demand (falling trade deficit). Now, yesterday, we learn that Japan has recorded its first outright trade deficit in 25 years!
Buy Buy Banks
Yesterday, Thursday, the FTSE 100 closed up 1.9% after falling 4.1% in the previous three sessions (& index is down 20% this year) and this morning fell 1.8% at the off. Gyrating up or down 2% is a normal day's shake 'n shiver, but there are interesting indicators below this. It is like watching racehorses at Aintree at the starting line of a steeplechase snorting steam in the cold air, jittery, spinning back and forth, riders adjusting checking all, thinking race strategy.
U.S. lawmakers neared agreement on TARP (with more protections for taxpayers or some kicking and ring scratches on the bankers)until McCain threw a spanner, as new data added to public concerns (WAMU, R-R-Recession, GE, Fortis and gosh, HSBC announces sacking 0.3% of staff?! And some chief portfolio strategist says, "It's an important watershed that the administration and Congress get this sorted, but it's not the key catalyst for buying the banks the next day".
OH BUT, NO BUT, YES BUT, it certainly is the 'key catalyst'- it's the flag about to drop or the starting gun cocked. Once financial stocks rebound significantly we will hear the complaints again that they're having it too easy; too much generosity gifted to these wastrels. It took 18 months after the introduction of the Resolution Trust Corp (RTC) to rescue the U.S. S&Ls in 1989 before U.S. banks started to outperform and many analysts compare the current plan to the RTC. But note the date. The banks started outperforming other stocks in the middle of recession! Starting from where they are now, chastened and pared down, outperformance is built in like a compressed spring.
Yesterday, jockeying at the start-line, Royal Bank of Scotland, HSBC, HBOS , Lloyds TSB and Barclays were up 1.8 to 7.1 percent. Insurers rallied too despite capacity in the insurance market falling, as capacity has fallen in banking too by about 30%, and so pricing is rising and dominant players like AXA can grow market. RSA Insurance soared 11.1%, Aviva 9.9%, Prudential 8.5%, Old Mutual 12.6% and Admiral Group 5.5%. These are very substantial moves but only the pre-start jockeying, and show the importance of TARP to the monolines and reinsurers and the whole insurance market, not just the banks.
3-month USD LIBOR-OIS spread jumped to record 199bp. 3-mo EUR LIBOR-OIS at 86bp (record was 93bp in Nov 2007). TED spread (3 month LIBOR/T-bill) at 316bp after whavering around 350-400bp. LIBOR rates at near record highs in USD, EUR, GBP. So, right now, there is no real term funding markets except for central banks windows and guess what, the Bank of England closed its SLS a few days back - the very event that probably triggered HBoS's rush into the arms of Lloyds. For now Libor is meaningless. It's for unsecured lending but there is no unsecured lending and all unsecured lending risk gradings of banks are awaiting downgrades. The measure of risk aversion and tightness in short-term bank funding by widening to almost 500bp, is the highest margin since the early '80s.
And what about the effect of banning short selling? Naked Shorting Continues in CDS Market (the onetime $62tn, now $54tn CDS unregulated dysfunctional market). Shortin has shifted to otpions and hedge funds can still bet against a bank in the unregulated OTT OTC CDS market without owning the underlying bonds in order to place a price fall bet. A bank bond short seller profits when the bond price drops further below face or goes into default.
Europe's banks (and Enhanced Money Market Funds) may now be more vulnerable than those in the US and more dependent on TARP going through. The leverage ratio (assets / equity) - of the average European bank is 35 (due to large in-house proprietary trading books), compared with less than 20 for large U.S. banks. This means small writedowns on assets have big impact on capital ratios. EU banks have become too big for any one European state to save while - too big to fail and too big to be saved; one reason the whit collar crime police have not been called in more often. Total liabilities of Deutsche Bank (leverage ratio 50+) are €2tn+ (one third more than Fannie + Freddie) or 80% ratio to German GDP. It may be well managed, but serious questions are being asked about other EU countries' banking champions.
So, of course, inevitably, this morning, Friday, the firing spring is coiled down again with banks down 0.9 - 4.3% (B&B down 14%) and insurers and listed hedge funds down 2.3 -5.6%. But other sectors and Europe and Japan are also sagging, hammocking.
Everyone is simply waiting for the folks on Capital Hill to ring the bell.
U.S. lawmakers neared agreement on TARP (with more protections for taxpayers or some kicking and ring scratches on the bankers)until McCain threw a spanner, as new data added to public concerns (WAMU, R-R-Recession, GE, Fortis and gosh, HSBC announces sacking 0.3% of staff?! And some chief portfolio strategist says, "It's an important watershed that the administration and Congress get this sorted, but it's not the key catalyst for buying the banks the next day".
OH BUT, NO BUT, YES BUT, it certainly is the 'key catalyst'- it's the flag about to drop or the starting gun cocked. Once financial stocks rebound significantly we will hear the complaints again that they're having it too easy; too much generosity gifted to these wastrels. It took 18 months after the introduction of the Resolution Trust Corp (RTC) to rescue the U.S. S&Ls in 1989 before U.S. banks started to outperform and many analysts compare the current plan to the RTC. But note the date. The banks started outperforming other stocks in the middle of recession! Starting from where they are now, chastened and pared down, outperformance is built in like a compressed spring.
Yesterday, jockeying at the start-line, Royal Bank of Scotland, HSBC, HBOS , Lloyds TSB and Barclays were up 1.8 to 7.1 percent. Insurers rallied too despite capacity in the insurance market falling, as capacity has fallen in banking too by about 30%, and so pricing is rising and dominant players like AXA can grow market. RSA Insurance soared 11.1%, Aviva 9.9%, Prudential 8.5%, Old Mutual 12.6% and Admiral Group 5.5%. These are very substantial moves but only the pre-start jockeying, and show the importance of TARP to the monolines and reinsurers and the whole insurance market, not just the banks.
3-month USD LIBOR-OIS spread jumped to record 199bp. 3-mo EUR LIBOR-OIS at 86bp (record was 93bp in Nov 2007). TED spread (3 month LIBOR/T-bill) at 316bp after whavering around 350-400bp. LIBOR rates at near record highs in USD, EUR, GBP. So, right now, there is no real term funding markets except for central banks windows and guess what, the Bank of England closed its SLS a few days back - the very event that probably triggered HBoS's rush into the arms of Lloyds. For now Libor is meaningless. It's for unsecured lending but there is no unsecured lending and all unsecured lending risk gradings of banks are awaiting downgrades. The measure of risk aversion and tightness in short-term bank funding by widening to almost 500bp, is the highest margin since the early '80s.
And what about the effect of banning short selling? Naked Shorting Continues in CDS Market (the onetime $62tn, now $54tn CDS unregulated dysfunctional market). Shortin has shifted to otpions and hedge funds can still bet against a bank in the unregulated OTT OTC CDS market without owning the underlying bonds in order to place a price fall bet. A bank bond short seller profits when the bond price drops further below face or goes into default.
Europe's banks (and Enhanced Money Market Funds) may now be more vulnerable than those in the US and more dependent on TARP going through. The leverage ratio (assets / equity) - of the average European bank is 35 (due to large in-house proprietary trading books), compared with less than 20 for large U.S. banks. This means small writedowns on assets have big impact on capital ratios. EU banks have become too big for any one European state to save while - too big to fail and too big to be saved; one reason the whit collar crime police have not been called in more often. Total liabilities of Deutsche Bank (leverage ratio 50+) are €2tn+ (one third more than Fannie + Freddie) or 80% ratio to German GDP. It may be well managed, but serious questions are being asked about other EU countries' banking champions.
So, of course, inevitably, this morning, Friday, the firing spring is coiled down again with banks down 0.9 - 4.3% (B&B down 14%) and insurers and listed hedge funds down 2.3 -5.6%. But other sectors and Europe and Japan are also sagging, hammocking.
Everyone is simply waiting for the folks on Capital Hill to ring the bell.
Thursday, 25 September 2008
WA WA WA MU!
WAMU, Washington Mutual Bank (founded in Seattle)the US's largest savings and loan one of the country's largest mortgage lenders, was taken over last night by federal regulators (FDIC) and instantly sold to JPMorgan Chase & Co. (No messing about, no competitive bidding; don't underestimate the regulator.) WAMU had assets of $307 billion and deposits of $188 billion, and is the largest traditional bank to fail in U.S. history (only 2% of assets or $6.1bn in losses in 9 months to June 30).
This is adding to the dismay and concentrating minds on clearing the $700bn TARP toxuc assets bailout fund through Congress. The BBC last night reported that the atmosphere in the USA seemed a hundred tmes more charged with anxiety that the UK was at the time of the Northern Rock bank run.
At the same time, over in the other Washington the bipartisan talks fell apart.
Presidential candidate Rep. Sen. McCain sided with House Republicans who now reject outright what the Fed and US Treasury propose and want an insurance based approach that has nothing to do with saving the banking system and only to do with mortgage-holder protection. Meetings reportedly dissolved into shouting matches. This is now make or break for McCain's presidential campaign. He is a self-confessed non-comprehender of economics, but is determined to back the conservative group's plan for Federal (FDIC-like or Fannie & Freddie style) insurance coverage for the half of all mortgage-backed securities that it does not already insure. That Rick Davis, McCain's campaign manager, has been paid roughly $2.5m over 5 years by Freddie Mac & Fannie Mae may be totally beside the point, but became central to the slanging match between Obama and McCain that began with McCain ironically accusing Obama of being advised by overpaid Fannie & Freddie executives who then denied that was the case?
The alternative Republican idea is to extend insurance cover to the half ofUS mortgages not covered by Fannie & Freddie (under Fed administration), meaning another $2tn+ of mortgages. What is the annual premium required for that these days and what will it ne when the only insurance cover buyers are Federal agencies? Deposit insurance rose to 130bp (FDIC cover for $4tn) but deposit risk is less than mortgage risk. Hence, it may not take more than a few years of mortgage insurance cover to absorb more than the $700bn bailout fund while generating no knock-on benefits, and possibly an enormous liability if the Fed has to self-insure its assets.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, rushed to Capitol Hill late last night to urge House Republicans to get back on track. Assuming the deal goes through as may probably be announced today (though I can't imagine McCain not succeeding in spinning this out until over and past the weekend. He would like to avoid the television debate this Friday, which can only be cancelled if this $700bn deal is stymied at least until then).
To get the deal through may now require the US Fed and Treasury to come clean on the immediate gains to the public finances. When the bailout was first mooted the markets jumped 8% across the board. What happens when the bailout deal is confirmed - maybe a 10-15% jump across the board? I expect the following gains from the $700bn and expect not all of the fund will be employed this year:
For private sector, $650bn gain approx:
- $400bn improvement in banks' asset valuations
- $200bn capitalisation gain via banks' share prices
- $40bn avoided in 1% deposit insurance hike on FDIC's $4tn of insured deposits
For public sector, $530bn gain approx:
- $100bn avoided in 2% deposit insurance premium on insured mortgages
- $100bn 10% gain to AIG's $1tn assets(now Federally owned)
- $ 85bn recover loan to AIG
- $160bn 10% gain to balance sheet of FM&FM $1.6tn assets/ $1.5tn liabilities
- $100bn 15% profit on RMBS etc. bought in by $700bn fund
to which can be added other gains in tax, lower cost of borrowing etc. Therefore, it seems to me that investing $700 billions for public and private partnership gains of $1.2 trillion is suspiciously businesslike!
This is adding to the dismay and concentrating minds on clearing the $700bn TARP toxuc assets bailout fund through Congress. The BBC last night reported that the atmosphere in the USA seemed a hundred tmes more charged with anxiety that the UK was at the time of the Northern Rock bank run.
At the same time, over in the other Washington the bipartisan talks fell apart.
Presidential candidate Rep. Sen. McCain sided with House Republicans who now reject outright what the Fed and US Treasury propose and want an insurance based approach that has nothing to do with saving the banking system and only to do with mortgage-holder protection. Meetings reportedly dissolved into shouting matches. This is now make or break for McCain's presidential campaign. He is a self-confessed non-comprehender of economics, but is determined to back the conservative group's plan for Federal (FDIC-like or Fannie & Freddie style) insurance coverage for the half of all mortgage-backed securities that it does not already insure. That Rick Davis, McCain's campaign manager, has been paid roughly $2.5m over 5 years by Freddie Mac & Fannie Mae may be totally beside the point, but became central to the slanging match between Obama and McCain that began with McCain ironically accusing Obama of being advised by overpaid Fannie & Freddie executives who then denied that was the case?
The alternative Republican idea is to extend insurance cover to the half ofUS mortgages not covered by Fannie & Freddie (under Fed administration), meaning another $2tn+ of mortgages. What is the annual premium required for that these days and what will it ne when the only insurance cover buyers are Federal agencies? Deposit insurance rose to 130bp (FDIC cover for $4tn) but deposit risk is less than mortgage risk. Hence, it may not take more than a few years of mortgage insurance cover to absorb more than the $700bn bailout fund while generating no knock-on benefits, and possibly an enormous liability if the Fed has to self-insure its assets.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, rushed to Capitol Hill late last night to urge House Republicans to get back on track. Assuming the deal goes through as may probably be announced today (though I can't imagine McCain not succeeding in spinning this out until over and past the weekend. He would like to avoid the television debate this Friday, which can only be cancelled if this $700bn deal is stymied at least until then).
To get the deal through may now require the US Fed and Treasury to come clean on the immediate gains to the public finances. When the bailout was first mooted the markets jumped 8% across the board. What happens when the bailout deal is confirmed - maybe a 10-15% jump across the board? I expect the following gains from the $700bn and expect not all of the fund will be employed this year:
For private sector, $650bn gain approx:
- $400bn improvement in banks' asset valuations
- $200bn capitalisation gain via banks' share prices
- $40bn avoided in 1% deposit insurance hike on FDIC's $4tn of insured deposits
For public sector, $530bn gain approx:
- $100bn avoided in 2% deposit insurance premium on insured mortgages
- $100bn 10% gain to AIG's $1tn assets(now Federally owned)
- $ 85bn recover loan to AIG
- $160bn 10% gain to balance sheet of FM&FM $1.6tn assets/ $1.5tn liabilities
- $100bn 15% profit on RMBS etc. bought in by $700bn fund
to which can be added other gains in tax, lower cost of borrowing etc. Therefore, it seems to me that investing $700 billions for public and private partnership gains of $1.2 trillion is suspiciously businesslike!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)